data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/464d7/464d718a89c93cd71428b470f0124672c7666c4d" alt=""
I've been drooling after the HiP Platinum Duo ever since I saw 2 of my favorite YouTube Gurus do eyeshadow tutorials featuring this product. I already had similiar colors & I'm super cheap, so I waited. I finally broke down & picked up the Platinum Duo because CVS had a BOGO! whooo hooooo!
So I compared the silver side of the HiP Platinum Duo
against NYX e/s103Hollywood
and L'Oreal Wear Infinite' 910 Rich Silver (dupe for MAC Silver Pigment)
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/9041a/9041af994c813614594bd0a68dd7ca3934490597" alt=""
as well as the shimmery black side of the HiP Platinum Duo
against
CoverGirl 440 Shimmering Onyx
and NYX es/01 Black (which is mostly matte w/ a hint of shimmer)
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/09616/09616d63d6a44fb5fed5536678dadc9ebba75af2" alt=""
I concluded from my swatches, that the investment in the L'Oreal HiP Platinum was well worth it's weight in gold. Here's why: That Silver is HAWT! It is peerless against the other shadows against which I compared it.
I rate the Covergirl more intense re: glitter. But if you would prefer to have less glitter, then the others are viable alternatives.
Here are the
SWATCHES! without Flashdata:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/87072/87072ed4241dd4e255fe9a308393b41f6c3c7f56" alt=""
Far Left is NYX e/s01 Black
Top Left is Covergirl 440 Shimmering Onyx
Bottom Left is Black side of HiP Platinum Duo
Top Right is NYX e/s103 Hollywood
Bottom Right is silver side of HiP Platinum Duo
Far Right is L'Oreal Wear Infinite' 910 Pure Silver
*Previously, I compared the shimmery Black from e.l.f.'s Drama Quad to CoverGirl's Shimmery Onyx & found the Covergirl to have more shimmer. This was what I wanted. So I didn't bother to include this in the comparison.
Happy Shopping!